|
|
3
|
2
|
1
|
|
Fiction and Nonfiction
Selection
|
·
Selections strongly related to each other
·
At least one article is taken from a children's literary magazine
·
Selections are appropriate in length
·
Grade level is correct
·
One selection is fiction
·
One selection is nonfiction
|
·
Somewhat related to each other
·
Neither selection is from a literary magazine
·
Material is too easy, too hard, or too long for a 4th
grade assessment
|
·
Not related to each other
|
|
Questions
|
·
Directions are clear and complete
·
Different graphic organizers are used in two questions
·
Graphic organizers are used appropriately
·
Two questions require students to support their answers
·
The questions that require support are implicit.
|
·
Directions are relatively clear
·
Graphic organizers are included in two questions, however, other
organizers may have been more appropriate
·
Questions are literal
·
Questions do not require support
|
·
Directions are unclear
·
Question format not followed
·
Graphic organizers are photocopies of the ones handed out in class
|
|
Writing Prompt
|
·
Associated with both selections
·
Topic, audience, format, and purpose are clear
·
Creative or related to real world issues
·
"Think Abouts" are included and
help guide the writing
|
·
Focused primarily on one selection
·
Prompt is not clear as far as topic, audience, format and purpose
·
Typical everyday writing idea
·
"Think Abouts" are general
|
·
Prompt is difficult to decipher
·
Directions are unclear
·
Pieces are missing
|
|
Standards
|
·
ELA standards, key ideas, and indicators are included and correct for
each question of the task (You should have these in 5 places)
|
·
ELA standards, key ideas, and indicators are included.
·
One set may not be included
·
One standard, key idea, or indicator may be missing or incorrect
|
·
Many issues with the standards, key ideas, and indicators
·
Many may be missing or incorrect
|
|
Model
|
·
Exemplar answer are given for each question
·
Graphic organizers are complete and correct
·
Extended response is well thought out, an exemplar answer
|
·
Questions are answered
·
Graphic organizers are complete
·
Extended response is complete
|
·
Answers are weak, drawn directly from text with little or no thought
put into them
|