Rubric

Magazine Review

 

 

A

B

C

D

Summary

Summary includes

·        Different parts of the magazine

·        Specific Features

·        Topics, Themes

·        Repeated Features

·        Layout

 

·        Some details are noted in the summary

·        Summary is lacking detail.  General overview given

·        No details are given

Critique

·        Analysis of many features and their relevance to children supported with examples

·        Analysis of many visuals supported with examples

·        Acknowledged pieces that were lacking and any concerns - supported with examples

 

·        Discussed some features - provide an example

·        Noted some visuals - provide an example

·        Acknowledged pieces that were lacking and any concerns - provide an example

 

 

·        Discussed a couple features

·        Noted  visuals

·        Acknowledged pieces that were lacking, concerns

 

·        Does not clearly critique the magazine. 

·        No examples are given to provide support

Use with Children

·        Description of different ways the magazine could be used in a classroom - supported with examples

 

·        Gave one  way to use in a classroom

·        Classroom ideas are general

·        No clear classroom ideas

Other Information

·        How often published

·        Cost

·        Age Appropriateness

·        Audience

 

·        Some information included

·        Little information included

·        Incomplete

Works Cited

·        Each magazine is cited correctly

·        Some magazines are cited

·        Few magazines are cited

·        May be incorrectly cited

·        No magazines are cited

 

Clark, C. F. (Ed.). (2004, August).  Highlights for Children, 60(646), 1-42.